This article first appeared in New English Review
I've been doing a lot of thinking about JD Vance lately, especially since the 2026 midterm election debacle. But even before the midterms, I have been having doubts about Vance as the presumptive 2028 Republican presidential candidate.
By any measure, Vance's life story is impressive. He was born into a poor family in Ohio that also suffered from great instability. After graduating from high school, he enlisted in the Marine Corps and served 6 months in Iraq in 2005 as a military journalist. Upon leaving the service, he went on to complete his university education before entering politics and eventually becoming vice president.
Vance's high point during the 2024 presidential campaign, at least in my eyes, was his debate performance against Tim Walz. Admittedly pitted against a hapless opponent, he made mincemeat of him-something President Trump failed to do in his own debate against another hapless opponent, Kamala Harris (in my opinion).
But Vance has said things as vice president that have caused me concern on several occasions. There was the ugly Oval Office scene in February 2025 with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, which Vance actually sparked and which was played out on television before a worldwide audience. Whatever disagreements existed between the US and Ukrainian leaders, they could have and should have been worked out behind closed doors.
The same month, Vance spoke in Munich at the annual security conference held there and sharply criticized the Europeans, singling out certain countries, for cracking down on speech. His words were true, but the manner and tone were not well received.
Contrast that with Secretary of State Rubio's speech a year later to the same audience in Munich. It was frank, but diplomatically delivered, and the moderator immediately announced that there "was a sigh of relief in the hall" that Europe still had a friend and strong ally in America.
Rubio arguably has been the star
of the administration. He has performed admirably and has won the respect of his
foreign counterparts. It would be a shame if his political career were to end
when Trump leaves office.
More recently, Vance has caused doubts to be raised as to the level of his commitment to Israel, as well as his friendship with conservative commentator Tucker Carlson, who many, including myself, believe has gone off the rails and crossed the line into outright anti-Semitism. Maybe we are reading too much into all that, and I am not yet prepared to call Vance an anti-Semite, but I support Israel, and I don't want anything that smacks of anti-Semitism in the Oval Office.
To close, this brings me back to Marco Rubio. This is purely anecdotal, but as I surf around the Internet, I am bombarded with conservatives expressing a clear preference for Rubio over Vance in 2028. Given what just happened in the midterms, many think that Rubio may be handicapped by his service in the Trump cabinet. If that is the case, many are suggesting Ron DeSantis. I am comfortable with him as well. Another person, whose name is not mentioned so much, is Senator Tom Cotton of Arkansas, who seems to me a sensible, sober conservative. I think he would be a great choice, at least as vice president. However, given the current climate, I greatly fear that if Vance is the nominee, he would be defeated by any halfway-reasonable candidate the Democrats put up. Thus, I would hope that President Trump stays out of the matter and lets the party fight it out.
No comments:
Post a Comment