For the past few years, we have been following the story of Saman Abbas, an 18-year-old Pakistani girl living in Italy, who was murdered by members of her family in 2021 in a so-called honor crime because she was refusing to marry an older man in Pakistan in a marriage arranged by her family, and because she wanted to live a Western lifestyle in Italy. Eventually, her parents, her two cousins, and her uncle were charged with her death, extradited from Pakistan, Spain, and France, and brought to trial in Italy.
Subsequent to verdicts by the court of first instance, the appellate court, and now by the Court of Cassation (which rules based on legal trial issues), the sentences are final. Life imprisonment for the parents and the two cousins, and 22 years for the uncle.
The article below from yesterday's Il Giornale is translated by Fousesquawk.
Homicide of Saman Abbas: Sentences finalized: Life in prison for the parents and cousins, 22 years for the uncle
The Court of Cassation rejects the appeals of the accused and confirms the sentences handed down on appeal. According to the indictment, the young girl was murdered for having opposed an arranged marriage and for having adopted a lifestyle deemed incompatible with family traditions.
-By Rosa Scognamiglio July 15, 2026 - 10:43
The Court of Cassation has confirmed all the sentences handed down on appeal for 5 defendants for the homicide of Saman Abbas, the 18-year-old Pakistani girl killed in Novellara (Reggio Emilia) on the night of April 30 and May 1, 2021. Therefore, the sentence of life imprisonment is finalized for the parents, Shabbar Abbas and Nazia Shaheen, and for the cousins, Ijaz Ikram and Noman Ul Haq, as well as the 22-year sentence in prison for the uncle, Danish Hasnain. The Supreme Court justices have rejected the appeals lodged by the defendants' lawyers, thus putting the final word on a long judicial chapter.
The prosecutor's indictment
Over the course of the indictment, the General Prosecutor, Marco Dall'Olio, had traced the steps of the tragic story, defining it as "chilling". Saman "had to be killed," the prosecutor explained. "The intention was to teach her a lesson: She could not decide her life for herself; she could not have her own life". The crime, "was organized down to the smallest detail, a concerted and premeditated act". And more: "The murder, despite having its own cultural roots, betrays the recourse to extreme violence, disproportionate, chosen as the only instrument to 'express an alleged guilt', the girl's desire for liberty, that caused the vile and ignoble motive." On appeal, the aggravating circumstances of premeditation and frivolous motives on the part of the accused were recognized.
The reactions
The verdict of the Court of Cassation as to the murder of Saman Abbas "represents a turning point on the social level even more than judicial". That was stated by Attorney Maria Teresa Manente, head of the legal department of Differenza Donna and civil attorney for the association. "Her death, " she adds, "was not an excess, an impulse, nor an accident within a distant cultural context: It was, as revealed by the same trial documents, a punishment. The process of killing her was born at the exact moment in which Saman dared to assert the right to choose who to love, to study, how to dress, how to live. Her freedom was her 'crime' in the eyes of her family, her life was the punishment". Attorney Rossella Benedetti, lawyer for the association, commented on the sentences: "The confirmation by the Court of Cassation finally brings justice to Saman and concerns all the 'invisible' women like her in our country who, every day, turn to our anti-violence centers asking for protection". Finaly, she concludes, "The sentence concern the ability of our institutions to promptly recognize the risk indicators present in stories such as that of Saman and to fulfill their obligation to guarantee, in a prompt manner, maximum protection."
The history
Saman Abbas was killed in Novellara, Reggio Emilia, on the night of April 30-May 1, 2021. The body was buried in a plot of land adjacent to an abandoned farmhouse not far from the residence where the girl lived with her parents and a brother. Dismissing the original theory of a voluntary departure, the investigations focused on the theory of a family crime, thanks also to the testimony of the young girl's then-fiancé. Images captured by surveillance cameras at the farm where the Abbas family worked showed some people walking towards the fields with digging tools in the hours prior to the alleged disappearance of the girl. Also reinforcing the suspicions of the investigators were the family's movements in the following days: the parents returned to Pakistan, while the uncle and the cousins tried to disappear, moving between France and Spain. All of the accused, at different times, were arrested and extradited to Italy. In November 2022, after information was provided by the uncle, the girl's remains were found. The autopsy confirmed that she died from strangulation. In February 2023, the trial opened in the Criminal Court of Reggio Emilia: The parents were sentenced to life imprisonment (the mother in absentia because she was still wanted), the uncle to 14 years, and the cousins acquitted. The public prosecutor appealed the sentence, maintaining that all the family members had played a role in the murder. In April 2025, the Appellate Criminal Court of Bologna partially overturned the verdict in the initial trial, sentencing the cousins to life imprisonment and the uncle to 22 years in prison. In the reasoning of the sentence by the appeals court, the judges explained that Saman was killed because her family did not accept her desire for independence and her wish to evade the rules imposed by her parents.
In fact, the young woman had reported her mother and father for maltreatment, and she was opposed to a forced marriage with an older man in Pakistan. In addition, she had shown a desire to adapt a lifestyle closer to Western customs and had asserted her right to be a free woman.
